Indo-European linguistics and classical philology
A. V. Lebedev The Theogony of Epimenides of Crete and the origin of the Orphic-Pythagorean doctrine of reincarnation (pp. 550–584)
Author
A. V. Lebedev (RAS Institute of Philosophy, Russian State University for the Humanities, University of Crete)
Pages\n 550–584
Summary\n
It is commonly believed that the epic Theogony of Epimenides of Crete derives from the corpus of pseudepigrapha under his name and that it was composed by anonymous author (with Pythagorean background) after 500 B.C. We demonstrate (mainly on the basis the reconstruction of the proem of the Theogony) that such influences do not exist and we arrive at the conclusion that the Theogony was written by Epimenides himself around 600 B.C. Aristotle who was sceptical about the authorship of the poems attributed to Orpheus and Musaeus, cites Epimenides without reservations as the real author of the verses he cites. Therefore the common elements between Epimenides on the one hand, and the Orphics and Pythagoreans on the other (Night as the first principle, the cosmic egg, the immortality and reincarnation of the soul), should be interpreted as borrowings by the latter from Epimenides, not vice versa. As a “priest of Zeus and Rhea” Epimenides belongs to the ancient Cretan hieratic clan that claimed descendance from Aiakos, son of Zeus; in view of the extreme conservatism of Cretan cultural, political and religious traditions, the sources of Epimenides’ divine wisdom should be sought not in the hypothetical “northern” or eastern quarters, but in the local oral traditions that go back the Late Minoan times and are closely tied with the cults and myths of the region around Mount Ida and similar oracular caves. The discussion of Epimendes’ herbal medicine shows that it is connected both with therapeutuc use of herbs and with cathartic rituals; Indian Ayurveda provides a close typological parallel to this, so common Indo-European roots are possible. After this we address the problem of the origin and the sources of the Orphic Theogony and propose a new solution. Taking at its face value Aristotle’s information on Onomacritus as the author of the Orphic epic Theogony, we discuss the “Cretan connections” of Onomacritus and adduce in favour of our hypothesis numerous literary and epigraphical-archeological pieces of evidence that connect early Orphism and the belief in the reincarnation with the Idaen cave and the region around it (Orphic golden plates and epistomia from Eleutherna and Sfakaki near Rethymno collected and studied by Tzifopoulos). Inter alia, we also propose a new interpretation of the Orphic graffiti written on bone plates from Olbia as divinatory devices (mantic cards, the oldest known ancestor of the cards Tarot) that probably belonged to the “diviner of Hermes” Pharnabazos of Olbia and were connected with the dice divination (astragalomanteia), the proper art of Hermes. The divinatory dodecahedron found in the Idaean cave seems to be connected with astragalomanteia, as well.
Keywords\n
Epimenides of Crete, Theogony, early Greek philosophy, divination, oniromancy, epic poetry, ritual slendering, rite de passage, Orphism, Orphic gold plates, pythagoreism, Pythagoras, soul, immortality, longevity, reincarnation, metempsychosis, Onomacritus, Aristotle, Euripides, Theopompus, Lion of Nemea, liar’s paradox, phytotherapy, history of herbal medicine, Ayurveda, Crete, Idaen cave, Eleutherna, Sfakaki, origin of the cards Tarot, astragalomacy (dice divination), Hermes, Apollo, Zeus.
References\n
  1. Diels H. Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker. Walter Kranz (Hrsg.). Band 1, Berlin (Weidmann), 1951, pp. 27–37.
  2. Jacoby F. Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker. Leiden, 1954. Nr. 457.
  3. Fowler R. L. Early Greek Mythography, vol. I: Text & Introduction. Oxford, 2000. P.111–137.
  4. Bernabé A. (ed.). Poetae Epici Graeci. Testimonia et fragmenta. Pars II, fasc. 3: Musaeus, Linus, Epimenides, Papyrus Derveni, Indices. Berolini et Novi Eboraci, 2007. P.105–168.
  5. Lebedev A. V. Logos Geraklita. Rekonstruktsiya mysli slova [The Logos of Heraclitus: A Reconstruction of His Thought and Word]. SPb., 2014. (In Russ.).
  6. Albinus L. The House of Hades. Studies in Ancient Greek Eschatology. Aarhus, 2000.
  7. Alimpertis Α. Futa tis Kritis. Therapeutika, aromatika kai edodima. Heraklion.
  8. Allan W. Religious syncretism: the New Gods of Greek Tragedy. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, 2004, vol. 102, pp. 113–155.
  9. Barnes J., Anderson L., Phillipson D. Herbal Medicines. Third Edition. London, 2007.
  10. Bernabé A. La Teogonia di Epimenide. Saggio di ricostruzione. Epimenide Cretese, 2001, pp. 195–216.
  11. Bernabé A., Jiménes S. C., Ana I. Instructions for the Netherworld. The Orphic Gold Plates. Leiden; Boston, 2008.
  12. Betegh G. Pythagoreans, Orphism and Greek Religion. Huffman, 2014, pp. 149–166.
  13. Blakely S. Myth, Ritual and Metallurgy in Ancient Greece and Recent Africa. Cambridge, 2006.
  14. Borgeaud Ph. The Open Entrance to the Closed Palace of the King: the Greek Labyrinth in Context. History of Religions, 1974, vol. 14, no. 1 (Aug.), pp. 1–27.
  15. Burkert W. Lore and science in ancient Pythagoreanism. Cambridge, Mass, 1972.
  16. Breglia Pulci Dora L. Osservazione sulla Teogonia di Epimenide. Epimenide Cretese, 2001, pp. 279–311.
  17. Capriglione J. C. La malva e l’asfodelo. Epimenide Cretese, 2001, pp. 37–52.
  18. Chaniotis A. A Dodecahedron of Rock Crystal from the Idaean Cave and Evidence for Divination in the Sacred Caves of Zeus. Gabrilaki I., Tzifopoulos Y. (eds.). Ο Milopotamos apo tin archaiotita os simera. Praktika diethnous sinedriou. Τ. ΙΙΙ. Archaioi chronoi, Idaio antro. Rethymno, 2006, pp. 205–216.
  19. Cook A. B. Zeus. A Study of Ancient Religion. Cambridge, 1925, vol. II, Part 1.
  20. Demoulin H. Epiménide de Crète. Bruxelles, 1901.‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬
  21. Dodds E. The Greeks and the Irrational. Berkeley; Los Angeles, 1951.
  22. Edmonds R. R. III The “Orphic” Gold Plates and Greek Religion. Further Along the Path. Cambridge, 2011.
  23. Faure P. Iera stilia tis Kritis. Heraklion, 1996.
  24. Federico E., Visconti A. Epimenide Cretese. Napoli, 2001.
  25. Federico E. La katharsis di Epimenide ad Atene. La vicenda, gli usi e gli abusi ateniensi. Epimenide Cretese. Napoli, 2001, pp. 77–128.
  26. Fowler R. Early Greek Mythography, vol. II: Commentary. Oxford, 2013. P.111–137.
  27. Giannadakis Ν. Iraklitos enantion Epimenidou. Ariadne, 1989. Τ. 5. Σ. 63–68.
  28. Gigante M. Il bios laerziano di Epimenide. Epimenide Cretese. Napoli, 2001, pp. 7–24.
  29. Graf F., Johnston S. Ritual Texts for the Afterlife. Orpheus and the Bacchic Gold Tablets. London; York, 2007.
  30. Huffman C. Philolaus of Croton. Cambridge, 1993.
  31. Huffman C. (ed.). A History of Pythagoreanism. Cambridge, 2014.
  32. Jaeger W. The Theology of the Early Greek Philosophers. Oxford, 1947.
  33. Kalogerakos I. Seele und Unsterblichkeit. Untersuchungen zur Vorsokratik bis Empedokles. Stuttgart; Leipzig, 1996.
  34. Kingsley P. Ancient Philosophy, Mystery, and Magic. Empedocles and Pythagorean Tradition. Oxford, 1995.
  35. Kirk G. S., Raven J. E., Schofield M. The Presocratic Philosophers. Cambridge, 1983.
  36. Koehl R. B. Aegean Interactions with the Near East and Egypt during the Late Bronze Age. Joan Aruz, Kim Benzel & Jean. M. Evans (edd.). Beyond Babylon. Art, Trade and Diplomacy in the Second Millennium B. C. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York, 2009, pp. 270.
  37. Latacz J. (Hrsg.). Homers Ilias. Gesamtkommentar. Band I: Erster Gesang (A), Faszikel 2: Kommentar. Berlin; New York, 2009.
  38. Lebedev A. V. The Cosmos as a Stadium: Agonistic Metaphors in Heraclitus' Cosmology. Phronesis. Assen, 1985, vol. 33, Nr. 2. P.131–150.
  39. Lebedev A. V. The imagery of lampadedromia in Heraclitus. ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑ. Athens, 1987–88, pp. 233–257.
  40. Lebedev A. Alcmaeon on Plants: A New Fragment in Nicolaus Damascenus. Parola del Passato, 1993, vol. 273, pp. 456 ff.
  41. Lebedev A. V. Pharnabazos, the Diviner of Hermes: Two Curse Letters from Olbia. Zeitschrift fuer Papyrologie und Epigraphik. 1996. Bd. 112, pp. 268 sq.
  42. Lebedev A. V. Parmenides the Pythagorean. Paper delivered at the 4th Biennial International Congress of the “International Association for Presocratic Studies” (IAPS). Thessaloniki, June 30–July 4th, 2014. (unpublished).
  43. Lebedev A.V. Idealism in Early Greek Philosophy. (unpublished).
  44. Iohannis Lomeieri Zutphaniensis. Epimenides sive de veterum gentium lustrationibus syntagma. Zutphaniae, 1700.
  45. Mele A. Il corpus Epimenideo. Epimenide Cretese. Bapoli, 2001, pp. 227–278.
  46. Nagy G. Homer the Preclassic. Berkeley; Los Angeles, 2010.
  47. Parker R. Miasma. Pollution and Purification in Early Greek Religion. Oxford, 1983.
  48. Poljakov Th. The nymph Balte, mother of Epimenides. Rheinisches Museum. 1987. Bd. 130, pp. 410–412.
  49. Schibli H. Pherekydes of Syros. Oxford, 1990.
  50. Seipel W. Das Artemision von Ephesos. Heiliger Platz einer Göttin. Wien, 2008.
  51. Strataridaki A. Epimenides of Crete: Some Notes on his Life, Works and the Verse Κρῆτες ἀεὶ ψεῦσται. Fortunatae,1991, 2, pp. 207–223.
  52. Tzifopoulos Y. Center, periphery or peripheral center. A Cretan connection for the gold lamellae of Crete. Edmonds, 2011, pp. 165–199.
  53. Tzifopoulos Y. “Paradise” Earned. The Orphic-Bacchic lamellae of Crete. http://chs.harvard.edu/CHS/article/display/5109.
  54. West M. Orphic poems. Oxford, 1983.
  55. Willets R. F. Cretan Cults and Festivals. New York, 1962.
  56. Zhmud L. Pythagoras and the Early Pythagoreans. Oxford, 2012.
doxygen 1.9.1